Why Most Growth Advisory Services Are Getting It Wrong (And How Smart Businesses Are Fighting Back)

Related Resources:

• Building Leaders
• Strategic Change Management Insights

Here's something that'll ruffle a few feathers: 67% of businesses that hire growth advisors actually perform worse in their second year than companies that muddle through on their own.

I know because I've been watching this industry implode from the inside for the last 18 years. Started as a bright-eyed management consultant in Perth, thinking I could save every struggling business with my shiny MBA and a PowerPoint deck. What a joke that turned out to be.

The problem isn't that growth advisory services don't work - it's that most advisors are selling yesterday's solutions to tomorrow's problems. They're still banging on about "synergies" and "low-hanging fruit" whilst the business world has shifted faster than a Melbourne barista during morning rush.

The Dirty Truth About Traditional Growth Advisory

Let me tell you about a client I had back in 2019. Manufacturing business in Adelaide, been running for three generations. Classic family operation - everyone knew everyone, processes that worked but weren't documented, relationships that mattered more than spreadsheets.

Enter the "growth advisor" they'd hired before me. This bloke walked in with a tablet full of KPIs and started talking about "optimisation matrices" and "scalable frameworks." Within six months, half their experienced staff had quit, customer complaints tripled, and the family was ready to sell.

Sound familiar? It should. Because this happens every bloody day across Australia.

Traditional growth advisory services fail because they treat businesses like machines instead of living, breathing organisms. They focus on:

Revenue optimization without understanding customer relationships. Cost reduction that destroys operational culture. Process improvement that ignores human factors. Technology implementation that nobody actually wants to use.

What Actually Works (Warning: Unpopular Opinions Ahead)

After nearly two decades of fixing other people's advisory disasters, I've learned some uncomfortable truths:

Small improvements compound better than big changes. I'd rather see a business grow 2% each month consistently than chase the 50% quarterly spike that burns out the team.

Culture trumps strategy every single time. You can have the most brilliant growth plan in the world, but if your people aren't bought in, you're pushing water uphill with a rake.

Cash flow beats profit margins. Controversial? Maybe. But I've seen too many "profitable" businesses close their doors because they couldn't pay the bills.

The best growth advisory work I've done has been with businesses that were brave enough to slow down to speed up. Take a Brisbane-based logistics company I worked with last year. Instead of expanding into three new markets like their previous advisor recommended, we spent eight months strengthening their core operations in South East Queensland.

Result? Revenue up 34%, staff turnover down 60%, and the owners actually take weekends off now.

The Human Factor That Everyone Ignores

Here's where most growth advisors completely lose the plot. They forget that businesses are run by humans, not algorithms.

I once had a heated argument with a colleague who insisted that emotional intelligence training was "soft skills nonsense" that didn't belong in serious business growth discussions. Two years later, he was out of the industry.

Because here's what the spreadsheet jockeys don't get: sustainable growth happens when people feel confident about change, not confused by it.

The most successful growth strategies I've implemented always start with understanding the emotional landscape of the business. Who's scared of change? Who's excited about it? Who's going to sabotage new initiatives because they feel threatened?

Address the human side first, and the numbers follow.

Why Brisbane Businesses Are Leading the Pack

I've worked across all capital cities, and I'll say this without reservation: Brisbane businesses are getting growth advisory right in ways that would make Sydney and Melbourne companies weep.

There's something about the Queensland approach - maybe it's the climate, maybe it's the culture - but Brisbane business owners are more willing to admit when they don't know something. They ask better questions. They're less concerned about looking smart and more focused on getting results.

A perfect example is a client in Fortitude Valley who runs a digital marketing agency. When we started working together, he said, "I don't want to be the biggest agency in Australia. I want to be the one that my team are proud to work for and my clients actually trust."

That honesty? That's the foundation of real growth.

We focused on team development training and authentic client relationships instead of chasing revenue targets. Eighteen months later, they've got a waiting list of potential clients and staff turnover that's virtually zero.

The Three Pillars That Actually Matter

Forget the consultant jargon. Real growth advisory comes down to three simple pillars:

People First: Before you change anything else, ensure your team understands and believes in the direction you're heading. This means proper communication, not just sending out a company-wide email with the new "vision statement."

Systems That Serve: Technology and processes should make people's jobs easier, not more complicated. If implementing a new system requires three training sessions and a manual thicker than a Sydney phone book, you're doing it wrong.

Sustainable Pace: Growth that requires your team to work 70-hour weeks isn't growth - it's exploitation with better marketing.

The biggest mistake I made early in my career was trying to implement everything at once. Clients would hire me for six months, and I'd try to revolutionise their entire operation by month three. Recipe for disaster.

Now I work differently. Month one is observation and relationship building. Month two is identifying the ONE thing that will make the biggest difference. Month three is implementing that ONE thing properly.

It's slower. It's less dramatic. It works.

The AI Revolution That's Coming (Whether You Like It or Not)

Look, I'll be honest - I was skeptical about AI in business advisory for years. Thought it was tech bro nonsense that would fizzle out like most Silicon Valley fads.

I was wrong. Not completely wrong, but wrong enough.

AI isn't going to replace human advisors (thank goodness), but it's already changing how smart advisors work. The data analysis capabilities are genuinely impressive. Pattern recognition across multiple businesses? Powerful stuff.

But here's where the human element becomes even more critical: as AI handles more of the analytical heavy lifting, the real value of growth advisory shifts to interpretation, implementation, and - most importantly - helping people navigate change.

A computer can tell you that your inventory turnover is suboptimal. It takes a human to figure out why your warehouse manager is resistant to new systems and how to address that resistance constructively.

What to Look for in a Real Growth Advisor

If you're considering hiring growth advisory services, here's my completely biased but thoroughly tested criteria:

They ask about your people before they ask about your numbers. Any advisor who jumps straight into financial analysis without understanding your team dynamics is flying blind.

They want to spend time in your business, not just in meeting rooms. I've learned more about operational challenges standing on factory floors than I ever did in boardrooms.

They have skin in the game. Be wary of advisors who get paid regardless of results. The best partnerships involve some level of outcome-based compensation.

They've actually run businesses themselves. Theory is useful. Experience is invaluable.

The Adelaide Revelation

Speaking of experience, let me tell you about my biggest failure and what it taught me about growth advisory.

2017, Adelaide manufacturing company, 85 employees. The owners brought me in because sales had plateaued for three years. Classic growth challenge.

I spent weeks analysing their market position, competitive landscape, product mix - all the usual consultant stuff. My recommendation? Expand into two new product lines and enter the Victorian market within twelve months.

Disaster. Complete and utter disaster.

They didn't have the systems to handle the complexity. Their quality control wasn't robust enough for new products. The Victorian expansion drained cash flow just as their core Adelaide market started contracting due to economic uncertainty.

Eighteen months later, they were forced to lay off 30 people and nearly went under.

The lesson? Growth advisory isn't about identifying opportunities - any decent business consultant can do that. It's about honestly assessing readiness and building capacity before pursuing those opportunities.

That Adelaide experience changed how I approach every engagement. Now I'm the advisor who talks clients OUT of expansion more often than into it. It's less exciting, but it's more responsible.

Where the Industry Is Heading

The growth advisory landscape is splitting into two camps: the high-tech, data-driven consultancies that promise to "optimize your business ecosystem," and the relationship-focused advisors who still believe that understanding people is the key to sustainable growth.

Guess which camp I'm in?

Don't get me wrong - data matters. Technology matters. But they're tools, not solutions. The solution is always human: helping business owners make better decisions, helping teams work more effectively, helping companies build relationships that last.

The future belongs to advisors who can blend analytical rigour with human insight. Who can read a profit and loss statement AND read a room. Who understand that sustainable growth is as much about what you don't do as what you do.

Final thought: The best growth advisory engagement I ever had lasted four years. Not because the client was slow to implement - because we built real capability instead of quick fixes. Their revenue tripled, but more importantly, their business became something they were genuinely proud of.

That's the standard every growth advisor should aim for. Not just bigger numbers, but better businesses.

---

Still not convinced that most growth advisory is broken? Fair enough. But when you're ready to try an approach that actually works, give me a call. I'll be the one asking about your people first.